You run a Shopify store, ads are live, and the campaign page no longer fits inside the theme editor. Two names keep coming up: PageFly and Replo. Short answer: budget and habit favor PageFly; speed and a testing culture favor Replo.
The numbers below come from both tools' Shopify App Store listings, their official pricing pages and an independent Lighthouse test; all sourced. To be clear: I'm a Replo affiliate, but I'm keeping this honest — I name where PageFly wins too.
Side by side: pricing, plans, capability
| Replo | PageFly | |
|---|---|---|
| App Store rating | 4.6★ (183 reviews) | 4.9★ (5,400 reviews) |
| Free plan | Build and test | 1 published slot |
| Paid entry | $99/mo (≈$82 annual) | $24/mo (5+ slots) |
| Unlimited pages | Included in Starter | $99/mo (Accelerate) |
| A/B testing & analytics | Built in (Experiments + Analytics) | A/B testing from the $24 plan |
| AI | Prompt, URL, screenshot + Figma plugin | AI credits (grow with plan) |
| Mobile Lighthouse (same content) | 79 | 52 |
Credit first: PageFly is the most-reviewed page builder on Shopify. The editor is mature, the community is huge, support runs 24/7. The free plan publishes one page; the $24 plan even includes A/B testing. If you need few pages, a low budget and a familiar drag-and-drop, PageFly won't let you down.
Speed: not cosmetic when you buy traffic
When you pay for traffic, speed isn't cosmetic: as the page gets heavier, part of what you pay per click goes to tabs closed before the page even renders. Reframe the builder question from “which looks nice” to “which loads fast” and the ranking changes — and in this test, the gap is wide.
The verdict
Simple rule: a few pages a month, tight budget, classic editor → PageFly. Serious ad spend, constant campaign tempo, a testing and measurement culture → Replo. Both have free tiers, so you can try both. My side is clear: Replo, for the design freedom, the speed and the built-in testing stack.
Set it up free, test your first campaign page.
Open your Replo account through my link — your first page ready the same day from a template or Figma, at no extra cost to you.